Thursday, August 2, 2018

Historic Tax Credit Update: The Sky is Not Falling, But Work Still Remains


By: Jason Yots, President, Preservation Studios

“This program was as good as dead”

I’m an historic tax credit attorney and developer.  I’m also an historic preservation consultant.  So, when Congress proposed to eliminate the federal historic tax credit (HTC) program last fall, let’s just say I had a few sleepless nights.

Fortunately, I had a productive outlet for my anxious energy through the loosely knitted coalition of HTC stakeholders and preservation advocates that made it their (second) job to retain the HTC program.  Industry groups and agencies at the national, regional and local levels led a relentless lobbying and advocacy campaign to save HTCs.  By any measure, the advocacy response on behalf of the program was unprecedented.  After all, the HTC program has performed so well, for so long, that there had never been a meaningful attempt to eliminate it, until the fall of 2017.  And the 2017 bid to eliminate the HTC was indeed meaningful.  As a Beltway lobbyist remarked at a recent HTC development conference: “I did not expect to be back here this year; this program was as good as dead six months ago.” 

But it survived.  Not entirely surprisingly, I suppose, given what the HTC program has weathered during the last ten years alone:  from an economic recession that crippled the construction industry (2008) to an anti-industry tax case that rocked the program (2012) to IRS regulations that countered decades of settled industry practice (2016).  Each of those events damaged the value of the federal HTC (as the 2017 changes certainly will), but none of them killed the program.

That being said, while the federal HTC program survived, it sustained a pruning.  The House’s slash-and-burn tax bill was draconian toward the HTC: outright repeal effective as of year-end, with a precariously short transition period for projects already underway.  In anticipation of the tax reform bill’s quick passage in the House, the HTC industry turned its attention, and lobbying efforts, to the Senate.  After topsy-turvy deliberations that initially included repeal, Senator Cassidy (R, Louisiana) led an effort to retain the HTC, proposing instead to downgrade it to a “five-year” tax credit (more on that in a minute) and to eliminate the “non-historic” 10% rehabilitation tax credit.  That proposal ultimately won the day, and the industry immediately moved to analyze the new law and its market impact heading into 2018.

Developers Jason Yots and Karl Frizlen leveraged Historic Tax Credit Investment
in the rehabilitation of 170 Florida Street, Buffalo NY


A Whole Lot Better Than No Credit At All

            A primary goal during tax reform negotiations was to find sources of revenue to offset the expensive tax cuts Congress sought.  On a dynamic basis, the HTC program more than pays for itself, once all economic activity resulting from the HTC investment is accounted for.  However, on a static basis, the HTC program looks like a give-away of taxpayer money because that method only accounts for the cost to the government.  Not surprisingly, the tax reform “scoring” process was largely static, and the HTC scored “high” enough to be lumped in with other budget-plugging cuts in the House bill. 

            The HTC program has always enjoyed bipartisan support, and bipartisanism ultimately saved the program.  The House’s static valuation approach, however, ignored one of the HTC industry’s strongest advocacy talking points: that the program is a lean government catalyst that sparks far more economic activity than it costs taxpayers.  Instead, HTC proponents emphasized more traditional arguments in favor of the program, such as the deep community impact afforded by many HTC projects and the fact that the program is an effective rental housing and middle-class job creator.  These more accessible grassroots arguments caught the attention of both politicians and their constituents, and the effort to save the HTC gained traction.

But Senator Cassidy and his coalition still needed to reduce the HTC program’s static cost to the Treasury to ensure its survival, leading to the five-year credit that became effective at the end of 2017.  Under the old HTC program, a taxpayer/investor receives her HTCs in the year that her project is “placed in service” (available for legal use).  Under the new HTC program, HTCs now are available “ratably” over the five-year period beginning with the project’s placement in service.  While reducing the hit to the federal budget, this shift also reduces the market value of federal HTCs because a taxpayer/investor is receiving the same tax benefit over a longer period of time.  From a simple time-value perspective, HTCs are now worth less than they were under the old HTC program.  In New York, we’re seeing this programmatic change translate into a $.10 - $.15 decrease in gross “pricing” for federal HTCs available under the new program.  On a $10 million project, that translates into roughly $200,000 – 300,000 in lost HTC value. 

While this lost HTC value will require more resources from developers and economic development agencies in the short-run, it will not kill many New York projects, in part due to proactive changes recently made to New York’s HTC program, explained in more detail below.  As a result, the general consensus among HTC industry members is that the five-year credit will remain workable for most deals, and certainly is a whole lot better than no credit at all.

The Sky Is Not Falling, But Work Remains

The good news is that the HTC program likely will survive for the foreseeable future; the not-as-good news is that the less valuable five-year format likely also will.  Whether or not Republicans retain control of the House in November 2018, it is unlikely that the sweeping “tax reform” that was accomplished in 2017 could be repeated any time soon.  In reality, past tax code overhauls have proven to be generational, at their quickest (the last was in 1986).  Also, the Treasury Department still has not issued most of the technical clarifications required to smooth over the hastily drafted and adopted 2017 law (for example, “ratably” was not defined in the new HTC law, but the concept is central to its operation).  To the extent that we do see Tax Reform 2.0 soon, it likely will be a much narrower bill that focuses on technical corrections to the 2017 law.  And, if Democrats gain control of the House in November, the HTC program is almost assured of survival, if not improvement.

While the sky may not be falling, there remains work to be done to protect and improve the HTC programs.  For their part, New York lawmakers acted proactively this year to separate and protect New York’s HTC from devaluation as a result of the federal HTC changes. First, New York HTCs were “decoupled” from federal HTCs so that New York HTCs will remain one-year tax credits, rather than five-year.  This change has helped to stabilize the market value of New York HTCs, and may even increase their value now that the federal corporate tax rate has been reduced to 21% (state HTCs are federally taxable).  Second, the New York HTC program was extended through the end of 2024, removing investor uncertainty that was growing in anticipation of the New York program’s prior 2019 sunset.

On the federal side, it will be an uphill climb to restore the federal HTC program to its 2017 format, whether or not the House flips in November.  This is due to a number of factors, including more pressing legislative priorities and a growing consensus among some HTC industry members to leave well-enough alone and focus on getting deals done under the new program.  However, while we may not see a feasible proposal to restore the old HTC program, we have already seen legislative efforts to improve the program in other ways.  Recently, a bipartisan group of lawmakers introduced the Historic Tax Credit Enhancement Act (S. 3058 and H.R. 6081), which would eliminate the requirement for a taxpayer to reduce her tax basis in an historic building by the amount of the federal HTC.  In short, that change would eliminate complications created by the 2016 IRS regulations mentioned above, would generally boost the net value of HTCs and would help to broaden investment options for HTC projects.

If we’ve learned anything from the 2017 tax reform, it’s that even a successful federal economic development program that has enjoyed bipartisan support for nearly 40 years is vulnerable to ideological shifts in Congress.  To protect against early extinction, HTC industry members and preservation advocates must remain battle-ready, even during apparent times of peace.  If we allow complacency to creep back in, we may be doomed to repeat history.

______________________

Jason Yots is the President and a principal of Preservation Studios (www.preservationstudios.com).  He also is partner in the law firm of Borrelli & Yots PLLC (www.borrelliyots.com) and the founder of Common Bond Real Estate LLC, a developer of historic properties in Buffalo, New York.

Tuesday, May 1, 2018

The Assassination Tour, William McKinley's Last Days

By Matthew Shoen

Associate Architectural Historian at Preservation Studios


On September 6, 1901 a pair of gunshots rang out at the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo. The President of the United States collapsed and Polish anarchist named Leon Czolgosz was arrested for shooting the President. Over the next eight days people waited breathlessly, praying for the President's survival. Unfortunately, the bullet wounds, coupled with complications from an operation to remove one of the bullets which had lodged itself somewhere in the President's lower abdomen killed  President McKinley on September 14, 1901. That afternoon Vice President Theodore Roosevelt came to Buffalo where Judge John R. Hazel swore him into the office of President.

The assassination of William McKinley led to widespread mourning as well as public outrage. On the day of McKinley's funeral the infrastructure of the entire country came to a halt for five minutes to mark the occasion. While many grieved, many more were angry at the ease with which Czolgosz carried out his crime. America had suffered its third assassination in 36 years and McKinley's death prompted Congress to authorize the Secret Service to act as full time guards to the president.

In Buffalo the assassination cast a pall over the Pan-American Exposition which continued for another two months and to this day Buffalo shares a morbid bond with Dallas and Washington D.C. as the only cities where an American President has been assassinated. Many of the sites crucial to understanding the assassination and its immediate aftermath are still standing and today I decided to create a guide for anyone interested in walking through the history of William McKinley's assassination at the hands of Leon Czolgosz.

Part I: The Assassination

William McKinley was assassinated inside the Temple of Music one of the many buildings erected for the Pan-American Exposition that was later torn down.1  After the Exposition buildings were torn down, the land was subdivided and sold to developers and prospective homeowners. The Parkside neighborhood developed over the exposition grounds and the historic tour begins in this neighborhood. Though the Temple's exact location will never be known, the Buffalo Historical Society placed a memorial rock at 30 Fordham Drive to commemorate the temple's approximate location.
The Temple of Music

Part II: The Assassin 

Immediately after shooting President McKinley, a mob of enraged and vengeful people piled on top of Czolgosz and started to beat him senseless. Eventually police officers pulled Czolgosz out of the Temple of Music and moved to Police Precinct 13 at 346 Austin Street in Black Rock. Czolgosz's stay at Precinct 13 was brief. Within days he was moved to police headquarters and later to Auburn State Prison where he remained during his trial and where he was executed on October 29, 1901 by way of the electric chair.

Police Precinct 13 
Part III: The Operation, Convalescence, and Death of President McKinley 

Immediately after being shot William McKinley was guided to a chair in the Temple of Music and from there conveyed to the Exposition's hospital building. Here two locals, Dr. Herman Mynter and Dr. Matthew Mann attempted to operate and remove the bullet that had penetrated McKinley's abdomen. The doctors worked in difficult conditions and had to reflect sunlight into the operating room to better see what they were doing. Further their attempts to probe for the bullet yielded nothing aside from the discovery of entry and exit wounds in McKinley's stomach which were sewn up. Following the surgery, President McKinley was moved to the home of John Milburn, the exposition's president. The house, sadly demolished in 1957, was located on Delaware Avenue near Canisius High School. McKinley spent the last eight days of his life in the house surrounded by doctors, friends, and his wife Ida McKinley.

The Milburn House

Part IV: The New President 

During President McKinley's last days, Vice President Theodore Roosevelt was kept up to date on the President's health.  Because McKinley appeared to be recovering, Roosevelt took a trip into the Adirondack Mountains. When word came of McKinley's death Roosevelt hurried to Buffalo taking a special train that had been ordered for him. Arriving in Buffalo, Roosevelt went to the home of Ansley Wilcox at 641 Delaware Avenue just a few blocks away from the Milburn House where McKinley had died hours earlier.

Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural Site

After Theodore Roosevelt's impromptu inauguration William McKinley's body was moved to Buffalo's city hall and from there to Washington D.C. Like Abraham Lincoln's body, McKinley's remains traveled by train from the capital back to his hometown, arriving in Canton, Ohio on September 19th. The country moved forward with Theodore Roosevelt as its president and though several of the critical sites related to the McKinley assassination have been lost, the event still looms large in the Queen City's history.

McKinley entering the Hall of Martyrs following his assassination





1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan-American_Exposition#/media/File:Pan-American_Exposition,_Buffalo,_1901.jpg






























Friday, December 15, 2017

Editorial: No, We Don't Drive Model Ts Anymore


By Joey Duggan, Associate Historian at Preservation Studios


The debate over how best to address the mounting concerns over the Scajaquada Expressway and Delaware Park invites contribution from all sides: the satisfaction of so many interests groups depends on which course of action the Department of Transportation decides upon. A recent editorial posted on Buffalo Rising offered a summary of the arguments voiced by some of the most active organizations involved in the discussion. The author of the post refuted these arguments, maintaining a position shared by many disgruntled motorists, at least partially on the grounds that efforts to preserve the integrity of Delaware Park “promot[e] nostalgia for a bygone era.”  In doing so, this author fell into a injurious rhetorical strategy, one that damages preservation efforts and threatens to doom bold policies to false epithets. Preservation does not simply mean saving old things because they are old. The compelling preservationist uses history as a reference in order to promote time-tested methods and structures for the benefit of the greater community. Preservation and the study of history mean looking backward, not for the sake of nostalgia, but for the sake of understanding. Placing the argument over the fate of the Scajaquada Expressway and Delaware Park as a moment in a series of trends enhances our understanding of the consequences of infrastructure.

One last glimpse at the park before Urban Renewal...
Courtesy of Buffalo Architecture and History
Advocates for a solution that promotes the interests of motorists on the Scajaquada frame the narrative as disagreement between obstructionists who relish in an idyllic past which they never experienced and rationalists who live in the modern world. Yet by positing the automobile as a pragmatic necessity, these advocates for a return to the 55 mph speed limit and a preserved infrastructure seem blind to the false paradigm upon which their advocacy depends. The nostalgia for the garden city of yesterday actually embraces principles in accordance with contemporary urban design; the fading plausibility of the city that prioritizes car traffic fails to reconcile the reality of successful urban planning in the twenty first century and threatens to doom Buffalo to perpetual decline. This dangerous dependence on the status quo ignores the empirical nightmare promised by prolonged dependance on the automobile.

Yes, the population of Buffalo today still outnumbers that of the city on which Olmsted stamped his design, but examine the numbers from the subsequent decades: after the implementation of Olmstead’s garden city design, the population of Buffalo skyrocketed. According to compiled statistics from the United States Census, it increased from roughly 117,00 in 1870 to 226,000 in 1890 and 352,000 in 1900. During the decades in which Buffalo’s population grew to equal and then surpass its present register, speculators such as Lewis J. Bennet, August Hager, and John C. Cook embraced Olmsted and Vaux’s plan by designing communities around the parks. The greenspace encouraged the establishment of so many neighborhoods that developed strong characters, such as North Park, Central Park, Parkside, and Hamlin Park. Of course a prodigious design for a park system cannot wholly account for the city’s massive growth in the fin de siècle, but ignoring the role that Olmsted and Vaux’s park system played in the meteoric rise of Buffalo shies away from a grand truth about the urban landscape. When city planners design projects to the benefit of the neighborhoods that host them, residents (and prospective developers and home buyers) recognize the harmony.


Olmsted's Garden city, c. 1896, a holistic design that allowed residents
to travel throughout the city by way of one network of unabridged greenspace.
Delaware Park was not a park within a city: Buffalo was "a city within a park." 
Courtesy of Buffalo Architecture and History
During the middle of the twentieth century, Buffalo’s population collapsed. Urban Renewal and the Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956 encouraged the construction of the Kensington and Scajaquada Expressways, and the city promised downtown accessibility for suburbanites and easier transportation between the city and the airport. Using the greenspaces created by Olmsted’s garden city plan as a skeleton, the designers of these expressways superimposed their structures onto tree-lined boulevards and cut through a number of neighborhoods. The structural integrity of some of these neighborhoods mostly survived this period of Urban Renewal, but for neighborhoods to the southeast of the park like Hamlin Park, the intrusion of the expressway system threatened to drive property values down and limit mobility and access to greenspace for homeowners. The residents of Hamlin Park demonstrated resilience, not complacency, in the face of Urban Renewal. They had purchased their homes in Hamlin Park before the destruction of Humboldt Parkway; their interests do not fall into the category of selfish speculation, for they have experienced the very real effects of the Expressway System on property values. While the residents of Hamlin Park were able to take advantage of the Model Cities Program in order to avoid deterioration and maintain property values, other neighborhoods on the East Side fared much worse during the Urban Renewal period. Naturally, the Parkside Community Association is not the only interest group voicing concerns about the adverse effects of the Expressway System on their community: Hamlin Park Taxpayers Association and the affiliated Restore our Community Coalition advocate for a rethinking of the Expressway System.


No, we no longer drive Model Ts. We have power steering and V-8 engines. We also have an unfortunate addiction to the fossil fuel lifestyle, and the symptoms of our ailment include profuse carbon dioxide emissions, a degradation of general well-being, and rampant proliferation of automobile accidents, which remain one of leading causes of death in the United States. Encouraging residents to enjoy the park system on foot or on a bicycle while discouraging the overuse of the automobile for short commutes is just another one of the small steps we continue to turn up our collective nose at, but the untenable attachment to gasoline and convenience threatens to topple our quality of life. If we cannot commit the time and effort to walk through and enjoy the scenery of the park on our way to our important destinations, how will we stand up to the looming catastrophe of global climate change? Of course, reality dictates that commuters continue to have the option to drive to work, but it does not dictate that our authorities engineer our city’s infrastructure to accommodate an unwillingness to adapt to the realities of the looming century.

Ford's Model T, the first ubiquitous automobile, hit the streets 
in 1908, years after Olmsted planned Delaware Park. 
Commuters still made it to work on time.
Courtesy of Wikipedia
Advocates for a return to the 55 mph severely overestimate the efficiency of the high-speed commute. According to the department of transportation, the Scajaquada Expressway measures about 3.59 miles in its current form. Applying the basic equation for speed as a function of distance over time, the amount of time it takes to drive from one end of the Scajaquada to the other at a speed of 55 mph is about 3 minutes and 55 seconds. Given the current 30 mph speed limit, the travel time is about 7 minutes and 11 seconds. That means that the original speed limit saves motorists about 6 minutes for a round trip commute, provided they travel the length of the Scajaquada and encounter no traffic. By privileging 6 minutes worth of an individual's time over the shared benefit of a more accessible and accommodating greenspace, these advocates demonstrate an underappreciation for the physical and economic wellbeing of citizens, the vitality of the city of Buffalo, and the concerns of future generation threatened by carbon emissions.

And no, Buffalo’s winter conditions do not encourage commuters to walk or bike to work year-round, but they also pose a major risk for commuters hurdling down an expressway at white-knuckle speeds. Sacrificing some time out of the day to strap on the winter boots and get some fresh air and exercise might sound laborious, but it pales in comparison to tragedy. The Scajaquada WKBW reported on the recessed rate of accidents following the speed limit recourse, I encourage the skeptic to take a look. The top comment on the aforementioned Buffalo Rising article also provides more general statistics regarding speed limits and safety. Although the prospect of trudging through snow in the early morning might make it harder to get out of bed, the side-effects of a daily commute on foot or on a bicycle outweigh the convenience offered by the automobile. A decision to promote alternative commuting methods by creating the favorable infrastructure encourages residents to make decisions informed by a breadth of factors, not just convenience alone.

Back in 2000, Michael Lewyn published, Car-Free in Buffalo, a guide to getting around Buffalo without an automobile. Seventeen years ago, Lewyn proved that it is possible to live in Buffalo, execute the duties of a professional job, and enjoy yourself, all without a car throughout the entire year. Moreover, he argued that mitigating congestion did not play a role in the economic vitality of American cities. Based on a comparison between the cost of congestion per motorist in specific cities and the rate of population growth or decline in these cities, Lewyn drew a conclusion with resonant ties to our current debate: congestion did not prevent people from moving to growing cities. Seventeen years later, Lewyn’s anecdotal observation still holds true:


“Indeed, common sense suggests that a smooth drive and a smooth economy do not go together. When a metro area grows, new residents flood the existing infrastructure, causing congestion. But when a city withers, the few remaining residents can enjoy a fast ride through deserted streets.”


The NFTA transit system might not be perfect,
but it delivers over twelve percent of the city's
residents to their places of work everyday.
Courtesy of NYCSubway.org
If authorities devoted taxpayer dollars to revamping our mercurial public transportation system rather than to maintaining and revamping high-speed expressways, and if we could muster the energy to encourage a culture of collectivist transport, we might not have to come to blows over the fate of a highway through the heart of our crowning park. The preservation and restoration of greenspace would come as a no-brainer.

Yes, Delaware Park has its flaws. Urban Renewal severed its tree-lined connection with Martin Luther King, Jr. Park. Most residents would sooner give up their hat than retrieve it from Hoyt Lake or Scajaquada Creek. The golf course dominating the meadow limits use of that space for the occupants of a number of tax brackets. The twentieth century undoubtedly took its toll on Olmsted’s design, but these changes cannot dampen the benefits of accessible greenspace for residents. The fact is, greenspace improves the quality of life for those who have access to it in innumerable ways. Olmsted recognized this reality and strung his greenspaces through not just the most well-to-do neighborhoods in the city, but also emergent middle class neighborhoods like those mentioned above. Adding insult to infrastructural injury, the destruction of Humboldt Parkway failed to recognize the democracy of Olmsted’s placement and tore the most proximate greenspace away from the residents of these middle class neighborhoods. Any decision to further detract from the park or its accessibility threatens to further damage the welfare of residents of all of the neighborhoods bordering the park. Privileging motorists at the expense of residents whose access to greenspace suffocates as a result of the expressway system’s stranglehold on Delaware Park, especially residents to the southeast, asks authorities to perpetuate the “business as usual” methodology that promises the further stagnation of the city’s economy. People do not choose cities based on how quickly they can drive their cars from one end of them to the other; they choose where they want to call home based on the quality of life offered by the places they envision.

Olmsted's Central Park, still expressway-free.
Courtesy of http://www.centralparktoursnyc.com/
How do other cities do it? So many of the most successful cities never opted for expressways through their greenspaces in the first place. Instead, urban planners in cities like London and New York opted for less intrusive beltline expressways and intra-neighborhood public transportation systems in order to ensure accessibility. In many cases, other cities faced equally difficult decisions during the Urban Renewal period, and even cities with economies that survived the twentieth century faced devastating policies and the placement of expressways which detract from their greenspaces. But in all of the cases worth imitating, greenspaces and the value of immediate properties survived. The grandeur of places like Olmstead’s Central Park might never have survived the intrusion of a multi-lane highway through their cores. The preservation of the holistic integrity of successful greenspaces promotes economic growth by ensuring residential stability.

A painting of Frederick Law Olmsted.
Courtesy of Wikipedia
I am not a member of any of the organizations which officially oppose the Department of Transportation’s plans or those who endorse any of the proposed quick-fix solutions. It is hard to imagine that changing the value of any number or any of the words scrawled across any of the signs by the side of the road will solve a problem that has festered for decades. I do not fully endorse any single agenda, but I do live here. I love provident design. I love the park system, I love Buffalo, and I love the planet that we all have to share. It pains me to see the discourse surrounding the issue plagued by a false paradigm. Conserving greenspace is not an attempt to live in the past, it is an effort to embrace progress. Calls to curb the selfishness of advocates for a restored park atmosphere lack self-awareness: reaching for a return to high-speed normalcy and sacrificing the wellbeing of the city itself to shave a few minutes off your commute ignores the best interest of Buffalonians in the future and falls into the category of obstructionist romanticization of outdated ideology. It would be foolhardy to return to heating our houses with coal simply because that is how it was done in the past, just as it would be foolhardy to return to the Scajaquada Expressway of yesterday for the sake of the very same sentiment.

We talk about resurgence these days as if it is a given, but unfortunately, the numbers disagree: our population still shrinks every year, and the only things standing in the way of Buffalo’s deterioration are deliberate decisions and hard work. Let’s stop designing a city for people who do not live here. Let’s embrace our own historic legacy and engineer a city for Buffalonians to come.